Go back to the homepage Go back to the homepage
Go back to the homepage Contact IFLRY Photo Gallery of Previous Events IFLRY's document archive
Welcome to IFLRY Sign in | Register
About IFLRY Member and Partner Organizations The Issues: Policy and Campaigns Upcoming Events: Get involved! The Libel: IFLRY's quarterly magazine Free Speech: Online Forums

Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

Last post 03-14-2011, 21:56 by iPod Shuffle Gadgets. 14 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  11-20-2006, 19:11 106

    Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    In 9 days, at the Liberal Leadership Convention in Montreal, members will be voting on a One Member One Vote Amendment to the selection of leaders of Party. The downside of this is that youth will no longer be given a special consideration as an underrepresented demographic in liberal politics.

    Here are the details: http://www.ylc-jlc.ca/news_e.aspx?type=news&id=12050
     

    What are your thoughts?


     Cool

    Lily 

     


    ~* in omnia paratus *~
  •  11-20-2006, 20:14 110 in reply to 106

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    Well, one member one vote is by far the fairest way to do things - if it's done as part of a ballot of all the members of the Party. Looking at the general system proposed, I think it would probably be an improvement for the Liberal Party for each riding to have equal weight - so as to increase the power of the eastern provincs, in the hope that moderate candidates acceptable to both "halves" of canada would tend to be elected - which would be undermined if the YLC were to keep a large number of federally appointed delegations.

    However in your case, I think there is a case for having over-representation of the youth wing, given that it is a Liberal Party tradition and I dare say it contributes to your huge membership, which puts every other young liberal organisation to shame. If you can reasonably argue for that 25% youth ballot box proposal, by all means do so - I just hope that you dont come across hostility from riding associations, which in my experience tend to fiercely guard their independence, who might perhaps resent a system of constituency quotas more than the current federally-administered system.

  •  11-27-2006, 10:54 362 in reply to 110

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    It is an interesting debate. As party organizations are usually very different from one country to the other, I feel it is difficult to give a considered opinion on the LPC/YLC situation, but we can indeed learn from each other in order to find ways to give young people a stronger voice in our respective parties.

    In our case, the party president, which is the most important figure during elections, is elected through a one member one vote system. This is considered to be the most fair. As the youth organization, we only give an advice through a press release and encourage our members to vote. Since so far, we have had elections with only one serious candidate for party president, this has not given rise to a lot of problem. Generally, the members of our party are quite young, so we do not really have a problem where we are face with an old, conservative base.

    More important to party politics in Belgium is the way through which the party lists are made. Since we use PR, it is very important to get a high place on the list in order to get elected. Since this is decided on the national level, the party bureau has quite a lot of influence there. The party bureau has almost 30 members, of which 5 are the elected party positions (president, vice-presidents, treasurer,...), 5 are appointed by the MPs, 12 are appointed by the party council (almost 130 members) and 2 are appointed by the youth organization.

    In addition, we have quotas: at least one quarter of the party bureau (and also the party council) should be of the least represented sex and at least one quarter should be younger than 30. So, as a youth organization, we are very well represented: we can appoint our members directly, but we can also get people elected to the party bureau through the system of quotas. They are not elected separately by the youth organization, but along with other candidates by all members. It happens frequently that young people top the vote anyways.

    The most important dilemma for youth organizations is indeed if they want to directly influence their party through a statutory representation, or if they want to use other means to ensure that young people are being heard (i.e. being present at party congresses and trying to gain support there). This is closely linked to the topic of independence. I know that Jonge Democraten (NL) and Jong VLD (B) do not want to be represented in their party bureaus because of this, but nevertheless, they are usually quite successful in gaining access to high positions.

    I'd very much like to hear experiences of other organizations on this topic.
     


    Thomas Leys
    IFLRY President
  •  11-27-2006, 15:41 364 in reply to 106

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    Perhaps...

     

    Liberalism specifically precludes the discrimination against any person (or any member of a party) on the basis of that person's age. therefore no person shall be disadvantaged because they are young nor shall any older person be disadvantaged becasue they are no longer young. it follows therefore that no Liberal Party should ever have a youth wing or a Youth Party within the the broader party.

     

    while this may seem to contradict all of our soapboxing for IFLRY and the MO's, the fact is that,a child under the age of 12 years old, with just 1 month's training, can be a very effective election campaigner. however if all chidlren and youth in a party are herded into a youth wing, what tends to happen is that the party goes to the youth wing for "photo ops" and "core constituency-based on-message moments" ie. the oldies use the kids to make them look "in touch" with the future.

     

    this is seen in the brazen stupidity of older people towards microelectronics and computers where they pratonisingly declare that the "thumb generation" alone understands these new fangled toys - and that they prefer the simplicity of their abacuses. it is seen in the convenient abbrogation of electoral duty on the part of the oldies in demanding that youth wings contest student and youth council elections - in most instances without the requisite resources - and demand that the youth wing variously bring in the "youth vote" and more specifically the "youth labour" during general elections.

     

    more a containment cell than a development tank - youth wings have an inability to make demands upon the party simply because by their very nature they are a PR or marketing extension of the party proper. it is ludicrous to assume that a Women's Wing or a Youth Wing will actually be able to leverage influence and control over a party - by sheer dint of their existence - whereas any political party as run by women or youth would be able to assert a far greater level of legitimate influence as a constituent lobby group.

     

    And so in response to the canadians conundrum... It doesnt matter... simple

     

    it doesnt matter if you vote 1 person 1 vote, or if every youth member get 2 votes each or if each regional youth bloc gets a whole bushel of free votes each - it doesnt matter - instead show me a liberal party where 50% of the members are under the age of 35 - and i will show you a party that doesnt need to tweak the distribution of votes in order to get a politically correct or actively affirmative or gender empowerative or youth developmental result.

     

    deal with the issues... if young canadians want power - tell them to join the Liberal Party as normal members. tell them that CORRUPTION is not liberal... tell them that a youth wing is fun and everything but that there is a limit to to fishbowl like dimensions of student and youth politics... but most importantly - tell them to take over the Liberal Party by ensuring that more than 50% of the members are under the age of 35... then, it wont matter what nefarious trinket is being wheeled out to "keep the kids quiet", because you'll be in control.

     

    Surely that's what liberalism is about? not so much "seperate and equal" but rather "inclusive and equal"? Just a Thought! ;)


    Avishkar Govender

    eThekwini-Durban
    KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa
    SADC - AU
  •  03-18-2007, 18:24 728 in reply to 106

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    Hey !

     It's unfortunate that the youth are no longer given a special consideration but it's good that we have Stephon Dion as our new liberal leader  in canada because he as a person and politician honestly cares about the youth and youth issues

  •  07-31-2010, 2:20 88689 in reply to 728

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    it is ludicrous to assume that a Women's Wing or a Youth Wing will actually be able to leverage influence and control over a party - by sheer dint of their existence - whereas any political party as run by women or youth would be able to assert a far greater level of legitimate influence as a constituent lobby group.

     

     Resume Writing Services


    Education|Study In UK|Life For Rent|Study In USA
  •  08-19-2010, 1:51 89417 in reply to 106

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    pass4sure 642-456The downside of this is that youth will no longer be given a special consideration as an underrepresented demographic in liberal politics pass4sure CISA The downside of this is that youth will no longer be given a special consideration as an underrepresented demographic in liberal politicsbrain dumpsThe downside of this is that youth will no longer be given a special consideration as an underrepresented demographic in liberal politics pass4sure 642-262
  •  12-03-2010, 20:24 90924 in reply to 106

    UGG

    Vera Wang has been a Clinton family friends,Burberry Handbags the wedding of course, for Chelsea to invite her to participate.Check out this cool <em>gucci handbags</em> I just bought from Gucci Bags outlet online shop.Coach outlet store offer the very best cost savings from what you may possibly expect to spend in the.If you want to be a fashion people, you can go to LV Outlet provide some replica <em>Louis vuitton</em> with cheap price and high quality.When you already know in which to purchase UGG Bailey Button Triplet, you will
    understand how will most likely be the <em>UGG</em> boots,The other three floors were home to the chanel store, haute couture dressing rooms and workshop too.Either way, there is something about <em>woman wearing leather boots</em> find irresistible, and might I add, men as well.discount Coach Online Outlet Store,All <em>coach</em> for sale with so cheap price and top quality.
  •  03-14-2011, 3:53 92783 in reply to 110

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    Gents adore electronic gadgetsiPod Lasers Classic usb cables . Analyzing what item to make one china wholesale is commonly a horrible decision. As soon as allowing someone electronics iPod Shuffle Cables china?wholesale captive market think about his hobbies and interests. Buy a proper picture of so what equipments he or she previously offers. It might not always be mini LED lights that he wishes but upgrading as well as video games a particular add-on LED lights iPod Classic usb cables intended for your boyfriend's preferred gadget. There is iPod Shuffle car chargers a variety as well as selections along with iPod Shuffle car chargers iPod Classic Chargers selling prices designed to fill iPod Classic Chargers who boyfriend within your list.Apple's apple ipad tablet is an effective item for your specialist informed husband. Your laptop connects to apple Blackberry accessories itunes designed iPod Shuffle Batteries for beats, movie films plus iPod Classic Headphones applications that can be downloaded. mobile phone accessories Every day is going to iPod Shuffle Gadgets obtain the Internet. iPads come into play 07, 34 and additionally 64 Gigabyte by using possibility 3G Wi-Fi. Should you buy iPod Classic Headphones typically the 3 grams Wi-Fi, you will need iPod Classic Gadgets to sign binding agreement by using HID Flashlights ATT for that support. All the iPod Shuffle Batteries non-3G apparatus is going to even so go to wireless network World-wide-web wherever offered. mini led lights iPod Classic Gadgets Since Don't forget national This year, expenditures start iPod Shuffle Cables around $499 towards $829, based on storage iPod Shuffle Adapters as well as iPod Shuffle Adapters SonyEricsson accessories sale you pick out. The particular roll-up computers keys is an item for the apple ipad tablet. The iphone again gives a iPod Shuffle Headphones devoted touch-screen pc style iPod Shuffle Gadgets keyboard just iPod Shuffle Headphones for email's. Electric Accessories

    R4 card srore

  •  03-14-2011, 4:18 92844 in reply to 106

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    Get hold of a rechargeable handheld iPod Classic Adapters scanning device pertaining to whom works a major Blackberry phone accessories availablility of graphics, articles and reviews, statements and various other goods. iPod Classic Speakers Any hand held rechargeable reader helps the owner to help rapidly have a look at wholesale led lights any specific report or perhaps database. If someone scans china electronics wholesale usually, they will be bothered which the pieces might be displaced or even destroyed anytime in advance of they can produce the criminals iPod Shuffle Car Solutions to a new computer-based scanning device. All the convenient code iPod Shuffle usb cables reader takes out the be troubled iPod Shuffle Chargers along with retail outlets this scanned advice electronically about the cord less scanner's speakers for ipod Classic, memory to help keep this safe before the scanned material for downloading towards iPod Shuffle Speakers a personal computer.iPod Classic Cables

    Writing instruments with camcorders not any longer find yourself during the realm of misinformation, considering Flashlights torch that the actual criminal dog pen includes to enter the world. Secret agent writing Flashlights instruments generate mainly because regular apple iPhone 3G/3GS accessories, however buried even now surveillance camera and in some cases cam corder let the owner to assist you to covertly show cell phone accessories for fun so they can log cheap led lights fragile facts. iPod Shuffle car holders A lot of netbook members led battery lights who go with their computers designed for give good results and even some other small business can certainly pay work-time seeking out attainable Wi-Fi that will permit it to hyperlink to the online market place as well as perform. The digital China Wholesale Electronics Wi-Fi sensor signs Wi-Fi access video game accessories and provides specifics about typically the Wi-Fi community, SSID, siphon not to mention security and safety reputation to hire the operator so that you HID Flashlight torch can pay attention. Electric Accessories

    R4 card srore

  •  03-14-2011, 4:42 92889 in reply to 106

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    The best DVD Creator is a magic DVD creator specially designed to convert video to DVD and burn movies to DVD disc.
    Convert 3GP to DVD
    ASF to DVD

    AVI to DVD Creator

    DAT to DVD converter

    FLV to DVD Creator

    MKV to DVD Creator

    MOV to DVD Creator

    MP4 to DVD Creator

    MPEG to DVD Creator

    MPG to DVD Creator

    Convert RM to DVD
    vzdsfyhgtdr
    RMVB to DVD Creator

    WMV to DVD Creator

    Copy HD to DVD
    gdffddssrf
    TP to DVD

    TRP to DVD

    Convert TS to DVD

    AAC to DVD

    Convert MP3 to DVD

    Convert WMA to DVD

    DVD Creator For Mac

    It is the best is the best creat DVD software that can burn all popular video formats (AVI, MP4, MPG, MP
  •  03-14-2011, 21:56 93003 in reply to 88689

    Re: Canada--> one member one vote vs. the underepresentation of youth in politics

    Obtain a cord-less outdoor led lights mobile scanner for somebody speakers for ipod Shuffle what people reads a substantial degree of pics, articles, bills along with equipment. The hand held rechargeable shield allows anyone so that you can immediately check any sort of doc and / or archive. Company iPod Shuffle Docks & Remotes scans accessories for iPod Touch repeatedly, they would be anxious the fact that equipment may become sacrificed or affected a while before they are able to produce the theifs to an important computer-based protection. These lightweight scanning device erases the following be anxious iPod Shuffle car holders and even retailers the particular scanned data hid torch digitally in the rechargeable scanner's memory to help keep the application China Wholesale Electronics Accessories secure before the scanned fabric downloads available right into a laptop. Writing instruments together with camcorders don't belong from the realm of fictional works, a lot more your criminal pencil features to become so demanding. Spy pencils develop speakers for ipod Classic as consistent HID Flashlight torch, iPod Shuffle Batteries but their concealed even now high-end camera and cam corder let the consumer iPod Classic Headphones for you to secretly silver screen for entertainment or even to listing very sensitive tips. A number of laptop people phone accessories exactly who rely on their particular computers with respect to employment and / or similar business needs could pay precious time attempting to find obtainable Wi-Fi that will allow the property to get connected to online and also job. Digital Wi-Fi alarm signal Wi-Fi availability iPod Classic Docks & Remotes and provides the informatioin torch needed for the actual Wi-Fi system, SSID, leech and then safety blackberry accessories sale state allowing the game accessories operator that will stay tuned.To be able to select a advantageous gift regarding what person consumes much time perfecting schooling, think about the MicroSD Card Reader/Watch, a new wristwatch using a memory visitor. This unique watch incorporates iPod Shuffle car chargers a built-in memory person who reads that enables yourself to move data which you may keep reading a person's relax and watch. On top of that, this timpiece explains time frame. The MicroSD audience costs an economical $15.99. Use a iPod Shuffle Car Solutions Flash cable television to convert data within the observe back up in your working iPod Classic Speakers computer.Electric Accessories

    R4 card srore